Insurance Denial: What to Do When Your Insurance Refuses to Cover a Prescription

THIS WEBSITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. The content included on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. Always consult with your healthcare provider regarding any medical condition and before starting any healthcare or medication regimen.

Receiving a notice that your insurance company will not cover a necessary prescription—whether for a brand-new medication or a routine refill—is one of the most frustrating experiences in modern healthcare. This denial often forces patients to choose between paying exorbitant cash prices or delaying treatment.

This guide provides immediate steps to secure your medication and the long-term strategy for challenging the denial, using CareCard as the critical stop-gap solution.

Step 1: Get Your Medication Now (Use CareCard)

The appeals process can take weeks, but your health cannot wait. The most critical first step is obtaining the prescription at the lowest possible price to ensure continuity of care.

The Immediate Solution

When a prescription is denied, your insurance will not cover the cost, and you are left to pay the full, high retail price—often $500 or more.

• The CareCard Advantage: A free discount card like CareCard will provide a negotiated cash price that is significantly lower than the full retail cost, sometimes offering savings of 50% or more. This allows you to fill the prescription immediately at a manageable price while you handle the appeal.

• Price Check First: Always use the CareCard platform to check the discounted price at local pharmacies (CVS, Walgreens, etc.). You must pay the CareCard price in cash (or with an HSA/FSA), but the immediate savings are vital.

Key Action: Get the medication with the CareCard discount, then use the denial period to work on your appeal.

Step 2: Understand and Challenge the Denial

Insurance companies have several common reasons for denial, and the path to an appeal depends entirely on why they said no.

Common Reasons for Denial and How to Respond

1. "Not Medically Necessary" or "Experimental": The insurer’s physician believes the drug is not the best course of action.

   • Response: Work with your doctor to write a detailed Letter of Medical Necessity (LMN). This letter must outline the patient's history, explain why the prescribed drug is superior to alternatives, and cite medical journals or treatment guidelines supporting its use.

2. "Requires Prior Authorization (PA)": The doctor failed to submit the proper paperwork for approval before ordering the drug.

   • Response: The doctor's office must submit the PA paperwork. Sometimes the denial is a simple administrative fix.

3. "Not on Formulary": The drug is not on the plan’s approved list of covered medications.

   • Response: Ask your doctor to submit a Formulary Exception Request. This is an appeal that asks the insurance to cover a non-preferred drug because the covered alternatives are medically ineffective or harmful to the patient.

4. "Step Therapy Required": The plan requires you to try a less expensive, often generic, drug first and prove it failed before they cover the prescribed drug.

   • Response: If you have already failed the generic drug, your doctor must document this history of failure in the appeal letter.

Step 3: The Formal Appeal Process

If the simple fixes fail, you have a legal right to formally appeal the decision under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). This process has two main phases:

Phase A: Internal Appeal (to the Insurer)

You and your doctor submit the formal appeal request to your insurance company. The denial notice will specify the deadline, which is typically 6 months (180 days) from the denial date.

• Timeline: For a medication you have not yet received, the insurer must issue a decision within 30 days. If the case is urgent (delay would seriously jeopardize your health), they must issue a decision within 72 hours.

• Documentation: Always include the denial letter, a detailed LMN from your physician, and any supporting test results. Keep copies of everything.

Phase B: External Review (Independent Third Party)

If your internal appeal is denied, you have the right to request an External Review. This is a review by an independent third party who is not affiliated with your insurance company.

• Final Say: The decision made by the external reviewer is binding, meaning your insurance company must abide by the ruling. This process is your last chance for coverage and has a high success rate (often 40% to 60% of external appeals are overturned).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I get reimbursed for the payment I made using CareCard once my appeal is approved? No. Once a prescription is paid for using a discount card, that is considered a cash transaction and cannot be retroactively reimbursed by your health insurance, even if the appeal is approved later.

Why is the insurance appeal process so long? The process is regulated by strict timelines, but the complexity of the medical documentation required (LMNs, medical records) often causes delays at the doctor's office. It requires persistent follow-up from the patient.

If I am denied, should I try the generic medication first? If your doctor believes the generic alternative is medically appropriate, it is often faster and cheaper to try the generic (using the CareCard discount to ensure the lowest price) rather than waiting weeks for an appeal. Always defer to your physician's guidance.

Can my doctor file the appeal for me? Your doctor’s office handles the most important part of the appeal—the medical documentation (LMN and PA). However, the patient must often initiate the internal appeal process and monitor the deadlines and status checks.